by Ben6993 » Mon Jan 11, 2016 10:01 am
I like the idea of clockwise (cw) and anticlockwise (c-cw) rotators as being the hidden variables.
However, the electron spin is an inherent characteristic of an electron and not just a classical idea of a rotating macro body.
Also, once you have two separate rotating bodies, their entanglement is gone unless you have say a further, separate hidden (eg multidimensional) connection between the bodies. Entanglement is a common, shared multistate which can be doled out at an interaction. That doesn't really fit your picture as your spin states seems to have been doled out before interactions with the detectors.
This is what would happen to a boat with a single rotor, with no rudder:
https://uk.search.yahoo.com/search?fr=mcafee&type=C211GB0D20151017&p=out+of+control+speed+boatThis is a boat which has lost its linear motion. You could get linear motion by including a rudder for counteracting the torqe. Not sure if an electron carries a rudder!

What I find to be kind of paradoxical is that the cw electron would, one might think, behave like the boat in the link which would appear to have a mass. And a c-cw electron would be like a boat curving in the opposite direction. But also with a mass. The paradox is that the LH electron and RH electron are considered to be massless, and also non-physical But if you put together the two forms of electron then the resultant body can be physical and have mass.
The photon seems to be like a boat with matching cw and c-cw rotors working together, which is of course the requirement for a very fast linear motion. And yet the photon is asymmetrical wrt spin, so it does not have matching rotors.

But the boats are just an analogy.
I like the idea of clockwise (cw) and anticlockwise (c-cw) rotators as being the hidden variables.
However, the electron spin is an inherent characteristic of an electron and not just a classical idea of a rotating macro body.
Also, once you have two separate rotating bodies, their entanglement is gone unless you have say a further, separate hidden (eg multidimensional) connection between the bodies. Entanglement is a common, shared multistate which can be doled out at an interaction. That doesn't really fit your picture as your spin states seems to have been doled out before interactions with the detectors.
This is what would happen to a boat with a single rotor, with no rudder:
[url]https://uk.search.yahoo.com/search?fr=mcafee&type=C211GB0D20151017&p=out+of+control+speed+boat[/url]
This is a boat which has lost its linear motion. You could get linear motion by including a rudder for counteracting the torqe. Not sure if an electron carries a rudder! :)
What I find to be kind of paradoxical is that the cw electron would, one might think, behave like the boat in the link which would appear to have a mass. And a c-cw electron would be like a boat curving in the opposite direction. But also with a mass. The paradox is that the LH electron and RH electron are considered to be massless, and also non-physical But if you put together the two forms of electron then the resultant body can be physical and have mass.
The photon seems to be like a boat with matching cw and c-cw rotors working together, which is of course the requirement for a very fast linear motion. And yet the photon is asymmetrical wrt spin, so it does not have matching rotors. :( But the boats are just an analogy.