Quantum computing infeasibility due to quantum tomography?

Foundations of physics and/or philosophy of physics, and in particular, posts on unresolved or controversial issues

Re: Quantum computing infeasibility due to quantum tomograph

Postby Joy Christian » Sun Sep 01, 2019 6:49 pm

Joy Christian wrote:***
The Argument Against Quantum Computers: https://indico.cern.ch/event/839574/

PDF of the talk: https://indico.cern.ch/event/839574/att ... 7/CERN.pdf


If so, then how many trillions will have been wasted? How many careers will have been ruined for raising a skeptical voice? And how many mediocre academics will have their careers made?

Joy Christian
Research Physicist
Posts: 2161
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 4:49 am
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

Re: Quantum computing infeasibility due to quantum tomograph

Postby minkwe » Mon Sep 02, 2019 9:21 am

Some people only learn the hard way.
Posts: 1128
Joined: Sat Feb 08, 2014 10:22 am

Re: Quantum computing infeasibility due to quantum tomograph

Postby gill1109 » Sat Sep 07, 2019 12:17 am

This article tells exactly why the quantum computing dream is going to become a nightmare. I have copy-pasted the text of the article on Phys.org https://phys.org/news/2019-09-quantum.html Emphasis on three phrases in the beginning of the article is mine. I have the feeling that these statements were "tongue in cheek" remarks. Indeed, Johansson and Larsson have shown how some famous quantum algorithms actually work, and they have shown that they do not always work as spectacularly as many famous publications suggest. In fact, they show that there is no point in building quantum computers for the sake of implementing some particular algorithms at all! Obviously, it would be politically incorrect to say this out loud.

Scientists at Linköping University have shown how a quantum computer really works and have managed to simulate quantum computer properties in a classical computer. "Our results should be highly significant in determining how to build quantum computers," says Professor Jan-Åke Larsson.

The dream of superfast and powerful quantum computers has again been brought into focus, and large resources have been invested in research in Sweden, Europe and the world. A Swedish quantum computer is to be built within ten years, and the EU has designated quantum technology one of its flagship projects. At the moment, few useful algorithms are available for quantum computers, but it is expected that the technology will be hugely significant in simulations of biological, chemical and physical systems that are far too complicated for even the most powerful computers currently available. A bit in a computer can take only the value one or zero, but a quantum bit can take all values in between. Simply put, this means that quantum computers do not need to take as many operations for each calculation they carry out.

Two degrees of freedom

Professor Jan-Åke Larsson and his doctoral student Niklas Johansson, in the Division for Information Coding at the Department of Electrical Engineering, Linköping University, have come to grips with what happens in a quantum computer and why it is more powerful than a classical computer. Their results have been published in the scientific journal Entropy.

"We have shown that the major difference is that quantum computers have two degrees of freedom for each bit. By simulating an additional degree of freedom in a classical computer, we can run some of the algorithms at the same speed as they would achieve in a quantum computer," says Jan-Åke Larsson.

They have constructed a simulation tool, Quantum Simulation Logic, QSL, that enables them to simulate the operation of a quantum computer in a classical computer. The simulation tool contains one, and only one, property that a quantum computer has that a classical computer does not: one extra degree of freedom for each bit that is part of the calculation.

"Thus, each bit has two degrees of freedom: it can be compared with a mechanical system in which each part has two degrees of freedom—position and speed. In this case, we deal with computation bits—which carry information about the result of the function, and phase bits—which carry information about the structure of the function," Jan-Åke Larsson explains.

Quantum algorithms

They have used the simulation tool to study some of the quantum algorithms that manage the structure of the function. Several of the algorithms run as fast in the simulation as they would in a quantum computer.

"The result shows that the higher speed in quantum computers comes from their ability to store, process and retrieve information in one additional information-carrying degree of freedom. This enables us to better understand how quantum computers work. Also, this knowledge should make it easier to build quantum computers, since we know which property is most important for the quantum computer to work as expected," says Jan-Åke Larsson.

Jan-Åke Larsson and his co-workers have also supplemented their theoretical simulations with a physical version built with electronic components. The gates are similar to those used in quantum computers, and the toolkit simulates how a quantum computer works. With its help students, for example, can simulate and understand how quantum cryptography and quantum teleportation works, and also some of the most common quantum computing algorithms, such as Shor's algorithm for factorization. (The algorithm works in the current version of the simulation but is equally fast—or slow—as in classical computers).
Mathematical Statistician
Posts: 1653
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2014 10:39 pm
Location: Leiden


Return to Sci.Physics.Foundations

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: ahrefs [Bot] and 0 guests

CodeCogs - An Open Source Scientific Library